Fateless, the movie

69mFateless, is a Hungarian movie (sub-titled in English) about a young 14 year old boy who finds himself in the midst of the Holocaust, that is really beyond his understanding.  It is a based on a semi-autobiographical book.  This young boy isn't even really connected to Judaism and isn't a very emotional kid at all. 

The movie has flaws but is haunting none the less.  The photography in this film is so unbelievable beautiful and brilliant that I got more out of that than the words being spoken.  The whole film is shot in black and white until the last few minutes of the film when it turns to color.  This is the first film on the Holocaust that I actually had a better feeling of what it might have been like to live through it. 

The main character, Gyuri, is who we follow through the film.  He first finds out that his father is being sent to the labor camps.  Everyone gets together for his last night to send him off.  This camera captures everyone's emotions.  The father's parents are there.  They zero in on the parents and the mothers confusion and the father tears welling up in his eyes and he stands up and runs to his son to hug him.  We had already learned that this it not a very emotional or touching family and that hug rips at your heart.

Gyuri find himself on a bus en route to work, he has a pass that has been issued by the army to do this. Regardless,  he is stopped, taken off the bus, with a variety of other people, and finds himself being transported to the camps.  What is most amazing is how everyone just went. 

The group of people he finds himself traveling with are both men and women, all ages.  Through out those scenes, the snow just continues to blow and circle around them in the car.  You can feel how cold they are.  As they leave Hungary, a guard comes and asks them to give him all their valuables and money.  He says that you won't need them where you are going.  Wouldn't they rather leave them in Hungary than with the Germans?  A man in their group attempts to negotiate for water with the guard.  This scene explodes with anger from the guard and dismay from the travelers.  It is a very haunting scene because the words that are flying back and forth are exactly how people felt about the Jews.  All money, all business and people hated them for it.  Great scene.  Very disturbing. 

When they arrive in the camps, the conversation prior to this is how they are told that they won't need luggage where they are going, but don't believe it.  Even one woman puts on her lipstick right before they exit the cart.  Once the army has separated the groups, the camera stills on the luggage just sitting outside each car.  It still sticks with me.

Inside the camps, Gyuri slowly disintegrates, as they all do.  The camera captures each persons own hell.  All Gyuri really wants to do is go home and eat.  He is hungry.  He doesn't truly capture his connection to why he is there.  I believe in the end he does, but it wasn't so obvious in the dialogue that we get as the movie winds down. 

Regardless of the flaws, I can not get this film out of my head.  The direction and photography make this film something to be seen.  Even the Germans who didn't believe that this actually happened and ignored the refugees returning home make you wonder and question.  I am glad my friend made me go see this film.  It will sit me with for quite awhile.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Joanne Wilson Joanne Wilson loves food, books, and music. She lives in New York City. Her husband Fred and children Jessica, Emily, and Josh are bloggers too. More »

gotham gal updates

RSS    Email updates    Gotham Gal Twitter updates

books of the moment

  • Jean Thompson: The Year We Left Home

    Jean Thompson: The Year We Left Home
    An American novel. We follow the lives of four Iowan siblings including a cousin and how their lives take different turns. An insight into life in the midwest and the family dynamics. Each chapter blends brilliantly into the next. Beautifully written.

  • Michelle Haimoff: These Days Are Ours

    Michelle Haimoff: These Days Are Ours
    Post 9/11 meets post college as young NYers return to their city after graduating. A super quick read with real characters. A glimpse of life in NYC, what is it like to follow in successful parents footsteps, the hardships of divorce, the difficulties of landing that first job and all the other angst that goes along at 20 years old. Really well done.

  • Georgia Pellegrini: Girl Hunter: Revolutionizing the Way We Eat, One Hunt at a Time

    Georgia Pellegrini: Girl Hunter: Revolutionizing the Way We Eat, One Hunt at a Time
    Girl Hunter is about a woman chef who fulfills her desire to really get back to the roots of cooking, killing what you eat. Pellegrini takes us through grouse hunts in the south to a weekend of hunts in England. As much as I appreciated her efforts and what she did, the book was just the same thing over and over. I wanted more. Each hunt, although different, was the same story each chapter. Conceptually, an interesting journey.

  • Bill Clegg: Ninety Days: A Memoir of Recovery

    Bill Clegg: Ninety Days: A Memoir of Recovery
    If you don't believe addiction is a disease, read this book. Keeping clean is the ability to just get through each day without suffering a setback. The separation between the head, knowing that you shouldn't and the desire is powerful. A terrible disease....and that is exactly what it is, a disease.

  • Alexis Maybank and Alexandra Wilkis Wilson: By Invitation Only: How We Built Gilt and Changed the Way Millions Shop

    Alexis Maybank and Alexandra Wilkis Wilson: By Invitation Only: How We Built Gilt and Changed the Way Millions Shop
    Really well done. Every entrepreneur should read it. They lay out exactly how they want from an idea to a multi-million dollar company and all the heartache, sweat and hard work that goes in between. Bravo.

  • Suzanne Collins: The Hunger Games

    Suzanne Collins: The Hunger Games
    Had to read this book after seeing the movie. The book is a quick read and well written. I saw the movie first so I thought they did a really good job of taking the book to the screen. I found the movie much more disturbing than the book. In the book, as always, you get better insight into what is going through the main characters head and perhaps that is why I didn't find it as upsetting. The main character is totally disturbed with the times they are living in which includes the Hunger Games that she has been picked to play in. Definitely finishing the trilogy.

  • Lauren Groff: Arcadia

    Lauren Groff: Arcadia
    This is the 3rd book that I have read of Groffs. She is an incredible writer with an interesting perspective and insight into people. Arcadia is set in upstate NY at a communal farm, true hippies. We get to meet all the characters through the eyes of a young child, Bit. As the years go by Arcadia falls apart and Bit has to live in the real world. I really loved the book. Amazing cast of interesting complex characters.

  • Rosie Alison: The Very Thought of You: A Novel

    Rosie Alison: The Very Thought of You: A Novel
    During WWII, in London, many children were displaced around the countryside. We learn about a mixture of characters who have been lost, loved and betrayed by relationships. War does strange things and this story is a small glimpse into just a few people and how that war affected them for years to come. Great first novel.

  • Jessica Maria Tuccelli: Glow: A Novel

    Jessica Maria Tuccelli: Glow: A Novel
    Unbelievable writing for a first time novelist. We follow 6 generations of a family who begins in slavery. In all honesty, I had a hard time following the book. It is dense and you seriously need to follow every sentence. Not that easy for me.

  • Chad Harbach: The Art of Fielding: A Novel

    Chad Harbach: The Art of Fielding: A Novel
    First novelist that was rejected by every publishing house until one young up and coming kid saw something in this book. Not quite sure why nobody saw anything in this book before as so much crap gets published. A great story that takes place on a college campus in Wisconsin all centered around the game of baseball. Really well written about a group of interesting characters with many flaws but manage to move forward in their lives. Really liked it.

  • Grace McCleen: The Land of Decoration: A Novel

    Grace McCleen: The Land of Decoration: A Novel
    UK writers first novel. An incredible book about a widowed father and his daughter who are religious zealots in a factory town. Faith works in strange ways. Really enjoyed the book. A real gem of a book that subtly speaks volumes about one aspect of society. A winner.

  • Liz Moore: Heft: A Novel

    Liz Moore: Heft: A Novel
    the opening pages made me just laugh. quirky book about two peoples lives that intersect at the beginning and the end yet are always present in each of their individual stories. a tremendously overweight man who never leaves his house and a woman who met him in her youth. we follow their lives and the people who come into them. a book about lonely people and although it is sad there is something endearing about the book. really enjoyed it.

  • Julie Orringer: The Invisible Bridge (Vintage Contemporaries)

    Julie Orringer: The Invisible Bridge (Vintage Contemporaries)
    I loved this book...cried at parts and cried at the end. We follow a Hungarian family, but mostly one of the sons, as he begins his education in Paris pre-WWII until the war ends. A beautifully written saga of a Jewish family living through terrible times. Bravo!

  • Amor Towles: Rules of Civility: A Novel

    Amor Towles: Rules of Civility: A Novel
    Set in NYC in 1930 we follow a young woman through her career and life. Definitely a woman before her time. Really enjoyed the book. Katherine Hepburn could have played the lead!

  • Gail Simmons: Talking with My Mouth Full: My Life as a Professional Eater

    Gail Simmons: Talking with My Mouth Full: My Life as a Professional Eater
    Loved it. If you love food and the industry that has sprouted across the globe, read it!