India...to go or not go to?

Gateway of India, MumbaiImage by Andy Hay via FlickrWe are supposed to take off for India in a few weeks.  We were very excited as we began to gather information about restaurants, stores, off the beaten track finds, etc.  Needless to say, our excitement has turned to ambivalence.  Should we go or should we not go?

We have all been scouring the Internet daily to learn more about the tragic events in Mumbai.  Hearing from friends and friends of friends with information and stories.  There are a million stories as there was on and after 9/11.  I just look at the pictures and read about the pain in all the hearts of Indians and my mind returns to 9/11.  How can it not?

Everyone has their 9/11 story.  Although we did not lose anybody close to us on 9/11, we knew people who did.  We also live downtown and watched the planes fly into the buildings, literally.  We walked up Sixth Avenue holding hands with our young children while people roamed the streets blood stained and covered with white soot.  Every day for weeks, the air would change with a fog and bad smell depending on which way the wind was blowing.  We did not feel safe with Bush at the helm, as it appears now, we were right in our assessment of his leadership or lack there of.

Although the city was buzzing the next day, as if nothing had happened, you could feel the change.  It was in everyone's face, it was in the body language.  There was an edge of fear but you had to move on.  We live in NYC, we can't just crawl under a rock because then the terrorists have won.  We all needed to return to our daily life with hopes that time heals all wounds.  And it did.

Yet, when another place in the world, that is just living everyday life, gets hit with an act of terrorism, it makes all of us take pause.  It brings back a rush of memories. 

On one hand, I know in my gut that India will probably the safest it has ever been in the next few months.  I know that there will be a slight edge to the country that didn't exist before.  I know that Indians will be thrilled to have tourists come and visit their country after a terrorist rampage.  But, will there be a war between Indian and Pakistan?  Will we feel scared while we are there?  Will we be jumpy?

At the end of the day, it is about the kids.  If it was only me and Fred, I wouldn't hesitate to jump on that plane, as planned, in a few weeks.  I don't want terrorism to rule the way I live my life. But, the kids, who were quite young on 9/11 (5, 8 and 10) shouldn't have to feel fear on their winter vacation.  

If anyone wants to weigh in on this decision...I'm all ears.  We plan on making this decision by tomorrow.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]
blog comments powered by Disqus

Joanne Wilson Joanne Wilson loves food, books, and music. She lives in New York City. Her husband Fred and children Jessica, Emily, and Josh are bloggers too. More »

gotham gal updates

RSS    Email updates    Gotham Gal Twitter updates

books of the moment

  • Cristina Alger: The Darlings: A Novel

    Cristina Alger: The Darlings: A Novel
    i LOVED this book. First time novelist. Well written. She does a great job of describing each character. The story is loosely based on a Madoff type character. Total NY story. Page turner. She knows her town and these people. Really LOVED this book.

  • Stephen King: 11/22/63: A Novel

    Stephen King: 11/22/63: A Novel
    This is my first King book. He is an incredible story teller. Quite a book, very creative, interesting idea and story. It is so long. 850 pages. I get why he is one of the best selling authors

  • Whitney L. Johnson: Dare, Dream, Do: Remarkable Things Happen When You Dare to Dream

    Whitney L. Johnson: Dare, Dream, Do: Remarkable Things Happen When You Dare to Dream
    I was so graciously asked to write a blurb for this book. It doesn't come out until May when I will write a post but for the time being you can pre-order. Here is my blurb; Every woman, regardless of age or profession, should read this book. Through stories of real women, their dreams and their struggles, Johnson's book has created an instant community. What's more, she has opened the door for women to empower themselves to dare, dream and do.

  • Russell Banks: Lost Memory of Skin: A Novel

    Russell Banks: Lost Memory of Skin: A Novel
    An interesting novel about the underground topic of child molesters. Banks takes on a disturbing topic as he weaves a variety of strange characters into the fold. Maybe I wanted some kind of closure from the book. The book is a big idea which really navigates a slice of America. Really well written but not so sure I'd recommend it. I stuck with the book but I didn't love it.

  • Susan Weissman: Feeding Eden: The Trials and Triumphs of a Food Allergy Family

    Susan Weissman: Feeding Eden: The Trials and Triumphs of a Food Allergy Family
    The name of the book says it all. Every parent and every teacher should read this book.

  • Tom Perrotta: The Leftovers

    Tom Perrotta: The Leftovers
    I have read a few of Perrotta's books. He is an incredible writer but I always feel so unfulfilled when his books end. This concept of this book is that one day random people disappear and the world changes. The book focuses on one particular community and a few families. At the beginning I was wowed by the premise of the book but as always his books begin to ramble and the end was so bad it was if he couldn't figure out how to finish it. Literally the last paragraph made me say to myself, "seriously"?

  • Alice Hoffman: The Dovekeepers: A Novel

    Alice Hoffman: The Dovekeepers: A Novel
    I wanted to finish it, I really did. But half way in I moved on. Really beautiful book. A story of four women who lived on Masada who are thrown together through fate as they tend to the doves. Wonderful history and interesting paths of each character. Just super dense. I hope to return to finishing it. After all...it is on my kindle.

  • Deborah Copaken Kogan: Between Here and April

    Deborah Copaken Kogan: Between Here and April
    This book tracks a terrible tragedy of a mother who took her life and her childrens in the 70s. I was interested in it because it happened where I grew up. Unfortunately the book bounces all over the place and only focuses on the authors own issues that she believes to be connected to this but in essence it is a serious reach and rambling.

  • W. Bruce Cameron: A Dog's Purpose

    W. Bruce Cameron: A Dog's Purpose
    It took me a while to get into this but a very clever book. Life through a dogs eyes. Really well done.

  • Kyung-Sook Shin: Please Look After Mom

    Kyung-Sook Shin: Please Look After Mom
    International best seller. Not only a peak into a past generation of Korean life but a disturbing look at alzheimers. Sticks with you.

  • Kathleen Flinn: The Kitchen Counter Cooking School: How a Few Simple Lessons Transformed Nine Culinary Novices into Fearless Home Cooks

    Kathleen Flinn: The Kitchen Counter Cooking School: How a Few Simple Lessons Transformed Nine Culinary Novices into Fearless Home Cooks
    Flinn writes about how she transformed 9 people to love cooking, understand food and what they are eating and basically changed their lives. Good book.

  • Julie Salamon: Wendy and the Lost Boys: The Uncommon Life of Wendy Wasserstein

    Julie Salamon: Wendy and the Lost Boys: The Uncommon Life of Wendy Wasserstein
    What a fascinating life. I actually liked the last 25% of the book the best. A woman of the generation that was told she could have it all and with all her success she still felt unaccomplished. A worthy read.

  • Michael Ondaatje: The Cat's Table

    Michael Ondaatje: The Cat's Table
    A beautiful memoir of Ondaatjes solo journey from Sri Lanka to London as a young boy of 11 to return to his mother who had been residing there for 3/4 years. Those 3 weeks made quite an impact on his life as he threads those stories back to his life as an adult.

  • Jeffrey Eugenides: The Marriage Plot: A Novel

    Jeffrey Eugenides: The Marriage Plot: A Novel
    loved this book. brilliantly written, great character development, literature references abound, questioning of religion, depression issues, post college angst. loved loved.

  • Julie Otsuka: The Buddha in the Attic

    Julie Otsuka: The Buddha in the Attic
    I read Otsuka's first book, When the Emperor Was Divine and really enjoyed it. Her writing is very distinct and her prose is written in a way that is different, imaginative and interesting. The book is a bit of an extension of the first book. The topic is on America's stained past during the war, in our own country, when we locked up all the Japanese people living here because of pure fear of nothing. Otsuka's book gives the read insight into how the Japanese lived prior to that time and really what wonderful immigrants they were and are. Opens up a chapter of American history that we should all be very disturbed by.