Question of the week #10

ImagesCan you elaborate on your perspective on raising a family in NYC? Do you regret leaving the city for the suburbs prior to being in your current financial position?

I love this question.  You can think of us as ahead of the curve or crazy for moving our kids back to the city at 8, 6 and 3 years old.  For us it was a dream come true. 

Since moving back, there is not a day where I am not grateful for living in NYC.  For our kids there are a million reasons why it has been a wonderful place to raise them.  Here are just a few. 

They have been exposed to a diverse culture of people, food, religions, economic differences and life choices living in downtown NYC and going to Little Red Elisabeth Irwin.  They have been empowered and independent since they began walking to school on their own from end of 5th grade.  They learned to be street smart when it comes to making decisions when one has to navigate a city.  They were able to embrace the cultural events, the latest store, movie or restaurant because they were curious about what was happening in their own town and the streets they were walking every day.  They have watched a neighborhood transform and with that comes a better understanding of how economies change and capitalism works. 

If we never returned from the suburbs then all 3 of them would probably have been different kids.  I can always find the good in anything and we would have been just fine in the suburbs but regardless of our financial success, which allowed us to make the move back, I am not so sure we would have survived there.  We probably would have figured a way back before anyone ever graduated from high school.  It wasn’t for us.  When I look back at that time period, although we made some incredible friends and those were wonderful years with the kids, I was probably depressed.  I just was not that happy being me. 

Perhaps they grew up quicker because of living in NYC.  Perhaps they are more sophisticated at a young age because they grew up in NYC.  But the bottom line is, happy parents make happy kids.  We are happy here.  We love this town like no other and if you ask our kids what is the best decision we ever made for them in their entire lives it would be making the move back to NYC.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Joanne Wilson Joanne Wilson loves food, books, and music. She lives in New York City. Her husband Fred and children Jessica, Emily, and Josh are bloggers too. More »

gotham gal updates

RSS    Email updates    Gotham Gal Twitter updates

ask gotham gal

Powered by Formspring.

books of the moment

  • Peggy Riley: Amity & Sorrow: A Novel
    A mother drives for days with her daughters and ends up in a random Oklahoma town after crashing the car. They come from a polygamous community where there were 50 wives. The mother had grown up knowing life outside that community. Over time, after leaving, she almost becomes deprogrammed. The realization of what she did to her daughters who no nothing outside the world they came from including how to read. Then there is the family that brought them in. It is a fascinating story. Well written. Worthy read.
  • Charles Graeber: The Good Nurse: A True Story of Medicine, Madness, and Murder
    An amazing true story of a male nurse who was arrested in 2002. I actually remember the story as I followed it in the papers. This nurse was a serial killer who had probably murdered over 400 patients that were under his care. A seriously well researched book. Great read.
  • Meg Wolitzer: The Interestings: A Novel

    Meg Wolitzer: The Interestings: A Novel
    Wolitzer writes about a group of camp friends who all come from different walks of life (some on scholarship) as their friendships continue through their mid-50s. At the beginning the story seems trite but as you continue to read there is a lot of be said. The story is sticking with me. She makes the case that everything that happens to you from your childhood makes an impact on who you become or don't become. Worthy read.

  • Elizabeth Strout: The Burgess Boys: A Novel

    Elizabeth Strout: The Burgess Boys: A Novel
    Strouts last book won a Pulitzer. She focuses on family issues. I enjoyed this book much more than Olive Ketteredge which I found utterly depressing. This book follows two brothers and a sister who live in the shadow of their fathers accidental death. Like most siblings, all have turned out very different yet they are connected. I did not love any of the characters, like her last book, yet as The Burgess Boys moves forward and memories are revealed, it is an interesting perspective on human character.

  • Tamara Shopsin: Mumbai New York Scranton: A Memoir

    Tamara Shopsin: Mumbai New York Scranton: A Memoir
    Great book. A witty spare inventive personal diary of Tamara journey from Indian to New York to Scranton. Really really enjoyed the book.

  • Michael Lavigne: The Wanting: A Novel

    Michael Lavigne: The Wanting: A Novel
    An incredible book that tells the human side of the many layered issues in the Middle East. From immigrating to Israel from Moscow, to being a victim of a suicide bomber yet surviving, to being pulled into an Israeli radical group. Each character is connected. Very layered well written book. Powerful

  • Alessandro Piol: Tech and the City: The Making of New York's Startup Community

    Alessandro Piol: Tech and the City: The Making of New York's Startup Community
    A history of the Internet that I lived through. Great job of recording what happened.

  • Amity Gaige: Schroder: A Novel

    Amity Gaige: Schroder: A Novel
    Not sure how much I loved this book. A father loses his child in divorce and decides to kidnap his own daughter. He is not a stable person but he obviously loves his daughter. His own childhood has made him a disconnected human being. An interesting journey but not sure I'd recommend.

  • Ernest Hemingway: The Old Man and the Sea

    Ernest Hemingway: The Old Man and the Sea
    Classic.

  • Janice Steinberg: The Tin Horse: A Novel

    Janice Steinberg: The Tin Horse: A Novel
    a good novel that not only tells the tale of another dysfunctional jewish family in the early 30's but interweaves pieces of los angeles history throughout the book.